Quant · Challenge question · Week 03

Quant challenge, week 03: exponents and number properties

One harder-than-average Quant question with a full worked solution. This week’s theme is comparing a number with its square and its cube, including values between 0 and 1 and negative bases, and telling a statement that must be true from one that only could be true.

By Devin Marsh, editorPublished 10 October 2026Last checked 10 October 2026Difficulty: hardTopic: exponents and number properties

This is an original question written for this page. The skill it tests is checked against the GRE Quantitative Reasoning overview from ETS and the GMAT exam-content page from GMAC. The byline is a masthead name, explained in full on who writes this, and the sourcing rules are set out on the standards page.

The question

If x is a real number such that x² > x³, which of the following must be true?

A. √(x²) = x
B. x³ < 0
C. 0 < x < 1
D. x < 1 and x ≠ 0
E. x² < x

Answer: D, x < 1 and x ≠ 0.

Worked solution

“Must be true” means true for every real x that satisfies the inequality, not true for one convenient example. The stem compares a square with a cube. The order of a number, its square, and its cube changes at 0 and at 1, and a negative base changes sign when the exponent changes from even to odd, so those cases have to be checked before a choice is kept.

  1. Rearrange. x² > x³ means x² − x³ > 0.
  2. Factor. x² − x³ = x²(1 − x), becausex² × 1 − x² × x = x² − x³. The inequality isx²(1 − x) > 0.
  3. Read the factors. x² is greater than 0 for every real xexcept 0, where it is 0. A product is positive only when both factors are positive, or both are negative. Here x² is never negative. So the product is positive only whenx² > 0 and 1 − x > 0. That is x ≠ 0 and x < 1.

x² − x³ = x²(1 − x) > 0, exactly when x ≠ 0 and x < 1

That is choice D. It is the whole solution set, not a sample from it, so it must be true. The arithmetic below is the check that the factoring did not drop a region.

  • x = 2, greater than 1. 2² = 4 and 2³ = 8. Is 4 > 8? No. Herex³ > x² > x, the reverse of the stem. Choice D also fails, since 2 is not less than 1.
  • x = 1. 1² = 1 and 1³ = 1. Is 1 > 1? No. The inequality is strict, so the boundary is out. And 1 ≠ 0, but 1 is not less than 1, so D fails here too, correctly.
  • x = 1/2, between 0 and 1. (1/2)² = 1/4. (1/2)³ = (1/2) × (1/4) = 1/8. And 1/4 = 2/8, so 2/8 > 1/8. The stem holds. The number itself is 1/2 = 4/8, so 1/8 < 1/4 < 4/8. That is x³ < x² < x. Between 0 and 1, the square is smaller than the number, and the cube is smaller than the square. D holds: 1/2 < 1 and 1/2 ≠ 0.
  • x = 0. 0² = 0 and 0³ = 0. Is 0 > 0? No. The factored product is 0 as well. D excludes 0, correctly.
  • x = −1/2, between −1 and 0. An even power of a negative is positive: (−1/2)² = (−1/2) × (−1/2) = 1/4. An odd power keeps the minus: (−1/2)³ = (1/4) × (−1/2) = −1/8. Is 1/4 > −1/8? Yes, because 1/4 = 2/8 and 2/8 − (−1/8) = 3/8 > 0. The stem holds. Line the three values up on eighths:x = −4/8, x³ = −1/8, and x² = 2/8. So −4/8 < −1/8 < 0 < 2/8, which is x < x³ < 0 < x². The square, 1/4, is also less than |x| = 1/2. On this interval the absolute value sits between 0 and 1, so the square shrinks it, just as a square shrinks a positive number between 0 and 1. The cube stays negative and is greater than x, because −1/8 is to the right of −1/2. D holds: −1/2 < 1 and −1/2 ≠ 0.
  • x = −1. (−1)² = 1 and (−1)³ = −1. Is 1 > −1? Yes. Herex³ = x = −1, and x² = 1 = |x|. D holds.
  • x = −2, less than −1. (−2)² = 4, positive. (−2)³ = −8, negative. Is 4 > −8? Yes. Compare: x³ = −8, x = −2, and x² = 4, sox³ < x < 0 < x². Below −1 the square is larger than the absolute value, because 4 > 2, and the cube is farther from zero than the base. D still holds: −2 < 1 and −2 ≠ 0.

The stem holds on both (−∞, 0) and (0, 1), and nowhere else. Choice D is exactly that set.

One root check, because it kills choice A. In the reals, √t is defined only fort ≥ 0. That does not throw x = −1/2 or x = −2 out of the stem: the stem never takes √x. It uses x² and x³, which are defined for a negative base. Separately, √(x²) is always defined, because x² ≥ 0, and it equals |x|, not x, when x is negative. At x = 1/2, √(1/4) = 1/2 = x. At x = −2, √4 = 2, and 2 ≠ −2. So “the square root ofx² equals x” is not true for every x the stem allows.

The method: regions, then must versus could

Split the number line where the order of x, x², and x³ changes:x < −1, x = −1, −1 < x < 0, x = 0, 0 < x < 1, x = 1, and x > 1. Test one value in each open piece, and test the boundaries on their own. A statement that fails on any value the stem allows is not “must.” It is at most “could.”

Two sign rules do most of that testing. An even power of a negative number is positive. An odd power of a negative number is negative, so the cube keeps the sign of the base. When the base is less than −1, the cube is farther from zero than the base. When the base is between −1 and 0, the cube is still negative but closer to zero than the base.

A square root in the reals is defined only for a non-negative input. Do not drop a negativex from a problem that only uses integer powers. Do not simplify √(x²) tox unless you already know x ≥ 0. The identity that survives a negative base is √(x²) = |x|. Factoring is the short proof once you see it; the region check is how you confirm the factoring did not lose the negatives.

Why the other choices are wrong

  • √(x²) = x (A) could be true, and it is not must. Atx = 1/2 the stem holds, and √(1/4) = 1/2, so A holds there. At x = −2 the stem also holds, because 4 > −8, but √4 = 2, which is not −2. The radical denotes the non-negative root, so √(x²) = |x|. That equals x only forx ≥ 0. The stem allows negative x.
  • x³ < 0 (B) could be true, and it is not must. At x = −1/2, (−1/2)³ = −1/8 < 0, and the stem holds. At x = 1/2, (1/2)³ = 1/8, which is not less than 0, and the stem still holds because 1/4 > 1/8. A negative base to an odd power stays negative. A positive base stays positive. The stem allows both.
  • 0 < x < 1 (C) could be true, and it is not must. This region does satisfy the stem: at x = 1/2, 1/4 > 1/8. It is not the only region. Atx = −2, 4 > −8, so the stem holds and C does not. A condition can be enough to force the stem without being forced by the stem. “Must be true” asks for the second of those.
  • x² < x (E) could be true, and it is not must. Atx = 1/2, 1/4 < 1/2, so E holds on (0, 1). At x = −1/2 the stem holds, but 1/4 < −1/2 is false. A square is at least 0, and a negative number is smaller than every non-negative number, so on the negatives the square is greater than the number, not less.
Takeaway

On a “must be true” question, one friendly value is not a proof. Find every real number the stem allows, including negatives and numbers between 0 and 1, and keep only the statement that survives all of them. Even power: positive. Odd power: same sign as the base. Square root: non-negative inputs only, and √(x²) means |x|.

Next reads