Quant · Challenge question · Week 02
Quant challenge, week 02: rates and combined work
One harder-than-average Quant question with a full worked solution. This is an original question on rates and combined work, published at this address. This week’s theme is pipes sharing a tank, including a drain and a moment when one of them stops.
This is an original question written for this page. The skill it tests is checked against the GRE Quantitative Reasoning overview from ETS and the GMAT exam-content page from GMAC. The byline is a masthead name, explained in full on who writes this, and the sourcing rules are set out on the standards page.
An empty tank has two inlet pipes and one outlet pipe, all working at constant rates. Inlet A fills the tank in 6 hours. Inlet B fills the tank in 3 hours. The outlet empties a full tank in 4 hours. The tank starts empty, and all three pipes are opened together. After 1 hour the outlet is closed, and the two inlets stay open. How long after the pipes are first opened is the tank full?
A. 1 hour 20 minutes B. 1 hour 30 minutes C. 2 hours D. 2 hours 30 minutes E. 4 hours
Answer: D, 2 hours 30 minutes.
Worked solution
Combined work adds rates, not times. A pipe that fills the tank in t hours works at 1/t of the tank per hour. A pipe that empties a full tank in t hours works at −1/t of the tank per hour. When a pipe stops, close that phase, write down the fraction still empty, and start a new rate.
- Rates. Inlet A fills 1/6 of the tank per hour. Inlet B fills 1/3 per hour. The outlet empties 1/4 per hour.
- First hour, all three open. The net rate is 1/6 + 1/3 − 1/4. The common denominator of 6, 3, and 4 is 12: 1/6 = 2/12, 1/3 = 4/12, and 1/4 = 3/12. So 2/12 + 4/12 − 3/12 = 3/12 = 1/4 of the tank in that hour.
- Fraction still empty. 1 − 1/4 = 3/4.
- After the outlet closes. The two inlets fill 1/6 + 1/3 = 2/12 + 4/12 = 6/12 = 1/2 of the tank per hour.
- Time for the remainder. Divide the fraction left by the new rate: (3/4) ÷ (1/2) = (3/4) × 2 = 6/4 = 3/2 hours. And 3/2 hours = 1 hour 30 minutes, because (1/2) × 60 = 30.
- Total, from the opening. The first hour plus the 3/2 hours after the outlet closes is 1 + 3/2 = 5/2 hours. And 5/2 = 2 + 1/2, so the extra half hour is (1/2) × 60 = 30 minutes: 2 hours 30 minutes.
1/6 + 1/3 − 1/4 = 2/12 + 4/12 − 3/12 = 1/4
1 + (3/4) ÷ (1/2) = 1 + 3/2 = 5/2 hours = 2 hours 30 minutes
The tank is full 2 hours 30 minutes after the pipes are first opened. The answer is choice D.
A bound check agrees. With no outlet, the two inlets need exactly 2 hours, since 1/6 + 1/3 = 1/2 and 1 ÷ (1/2) = 2. The outlet ran for an hour, so the real total is longer than 2 hours. If the outlet had stayed open, the net rate would have stayed 1/4 and the tank would have taken 4 hours. It closed, so the real total is shorter than 4 hours. The only choice strictly between 2 hours and 4 hours is 2 hours 30 minutes.
The method: add rates, then split the job
Convert every given time to a fraction of the job per hour before combining anything. Add those fractions when the pipes run together. Subtract a drain; do not add it, and do not average the three times. If a pipe stops, the job has two phases. The time for a phase is the fraction of the tank handled in that phase, divided by the rate during that phase. The clock in the question starts when the pipes are first opened, so add the phases at the end and convert any leftover fraction of an hour into minutes with × 60.
Why the other choices are wrong
- 1 hour 20 minutes (A) treats the outlet as a third inlet and never closes it. 1/6 + 1/3 + 1/4 = 2/12 + 4/12 + 3/12 = 9/12 = 3/4 of the tank per hour. The whole job at that rate takes 1 ÷ (3/4) = 4/3 hours. One third of 60 minutes is 20, so 4/3 hours is 1 hour 20 minutes. The outlet removes water, so its rate is negative, and it is open for only the first hour. This total is also faster than the no-outlet time of 2 hours, which a drain cannot do.
- 1 hour 30 minutes (B) is the second phase alone: (3/4) ÷ (1/2) = 3/2 hours, and (1/2) × 60 = 30, so 1 hour 30 minutes. That is how long the inlets need after the outlet closes. The question asks for the time from the moment the pipes are first opened, which includes the first hour. As a total, 1 hour 30 minutes is also under the 2-hour no-outlet bound.
- 2 hours (C) ignores the outlet. 1/6 + 1/3 = 1/2 per hour, and 1 ÷ (1/2) = 2 hours. That is the time if only the two inlets had been open from the start. The outlet removed 1/4 of a tank during the first hour, so the finish is later than this.
- 4 hours (E) leaves the outlet open for the whole job. The three-pipe rate is 1/4 per hour, and 1 ÷ (1/4) = 4 hours. The outlet closes after 1 hour, so the later rate is 1/2, not 1/4, and the finish is earlier than this.
On a combined-work question, turn each time into a rate, then add. A drain is a minus. If one of them stops, bank the fraction already done and rebuild the rate from what is still running. Match the clock the question named, not the length of the last phase alone.